11 TV Shows That Had A Successful Start But Progressively Worsened Over Time

New television shows can captivate audiences, drawing us into compelling narratives and endearing characters that become a part of our lives. Some are rare gems that burst onto the scene with a devoted following, leaving us eagerly anticipating each new episode. Yet, as time passes, some of these shows gradually lose their magic, succumbing to a decline in quality and disillusioning viewers.

1. Game of Thrones

Game of Thrones HBO
Image Credit: HBO.

When Game of Thrones premiered in 2011, it quickly captivated audiences with its intricate plotlines, complex characters, and unexpected twists. However, as the series progressed and eventually surpassed the storyline of the source material, George R.R. Martin’s books, it began to lose its grip on viewers. The rushed pacing, questionable character development, and controversial narrative decisions in the final seasons left many fans feeling unsatisfied and disappointed.

2. Dexter

dexter showtime
Image Credit: Showtime.

Dexter, the dark and gripping crime drama, hooked audiences with its unique premise of a blood-spatter analyst who moonlights as a serial killer. The first few seasons showcased brilliant writing and intense storytelling that kept viewers on the edge of their seats. However, as the series continued, it fell victim to repetitive storylines and a lack of character growth. The final season, in particular, received significant backlash for its anticlimactic ending, leaving fans feeling let down.

3. The Walking Dead

the walking dead AMC
Image Credit: AMC…

The Walking Dead burst onto the scene as a fresh take on the zombie apocalypse genre, presenting a gritty and realistic portrayal of survival in a post-apocalyptic world. The initial seasons were hailed for their strong character development and thrilling plotlines. However, as the show progressed, it began to suffer from pacing issues and a tendency to drag out story arcs. The departure of key characters and repetitive conflicts led to a decline in viewership and a sense of fatigue among the fanbase.

4. Lost

Lost ABC
Image Credit: ABC,

Lost mesmerized audiences with its mysterious island, intricate mythology, and compelling ensemble cast when it premiered in 2004. The first few seasons were filled with suspense, intriguing plot twists, and a sense of wonder. However, as the series continued, the focus on answering questions and resolving mysteries seemed to take precedence over coherent storytelling. The introduction of new plot elements and confusing time travel aspects left viewers frustrated, ultimately leading to a divisive finale that left many unresolved questions.

5. Heroes

Heroes NBC
Image Credit: NBC.

Heroes burst onto the scene in 2006, offering a fresh take on the superhero genre with its ensemble cast of characters discovering their extraordinary abilities. The initial season captivated audiences with its complex narrative and morally ambiguous characters. However, subsequent seasons struggled to maintain the same level of quality, with convoluted storylines, inconsistent character arcs, and a lack of clear direction. The show’s decline in viewership and critical acclaim led to its cancellation after four seasons.

6. The Office

the office NBC
Image Credit: NBC.

The Office debuted in 2005 and quickly became a beloved mockumentary sitcom that provided viewers with hilarious workplace antics. The early seasons showcased a perfect blend of wit, clever writing, and memorable characters. However, as the show progressed, some fans felt that the quality declined, particularly after the departure of key cast members. The later seasons struggled to capture the same magic, relying on repetitive storylines and exaggerated character traits, which led to a sense of fatigue and a loss of the show’s original charm.

7. Glee

Image Credit: Fox.

Glee, a musical dramedy that premiered in 2009, brought the joy of singing and dancing to television screens. The initial seasons were celebrated for their catchy musical performances, relatable characters, and inclusive storytelling. However, as the show continued, it became plagued with inconsistent writing, unrealistic plotlines, and an overwhelming focus on unnecessary guest stars. The once-heartfelt and inspiring series lost its way, leading to a decline in viewership and a lack of emotional resonance.

8. Prison Break

prison break
Image Credit: Fox.

Prison Break burst onto the scene in 2005, captivating audiences with its high-stakes premise of a man orchestrating an elaborate plan to break his wrongfully convicted brother out of prison. The first season delivered intense thrills, intricate plotting, and nail-biting suspense. However, as the show progressed, it struggled to maintain the same level of excitement and believability. The subsequent seasons introduced convoluted storylines and repetitive prison escapes, diluting the original concept and leaving viewers longing for the initial brilliance of the show.

9. True Blood

true blood HBO
Image Credit: HBO.

True Blood, a supernatural drama series based on Charlaine Harris’s novels, debuted in 2008 and brought vampires, werewolves, and other mythical creatures into the mainstream. The early seasons were praised for their unique blend of horror, romance, and social commentary. However, as the show continued, it became mired in excessive subplots, inconsistent character arcs, and a lack of narrative focus. The later seasons deviated from the show’s original essence, leading to a decline in quality and a loss of interest from once-dedicated fans.

10. How I Met Your Mother

how I met your mother CBS
Image Credit: CBS.

How I Met Your Mother premiered in 2005 as a heartfelt and humorous sitcom that followed the romantic misadventures of a group of friends in New York City. The early seasons gave viewers endearing characters, witty writing, and a compelling central mystery. However, as the show progressed and its titular question remained unanswered, fans grew frustrated with the prolonged storytelling. The later seasons introduced unnecessary plot twists and character developments that didn’t resonate with the audience, ultimately tarnishing the legacy of the once-beloved series.

11. The Blacklist

The Blacklist 1
Image Credit: NBCUniversal Television

The American thriller series, The Blacklist, lasted a decade, with James Spader’s character, the pithy Raymond Reddington, who has eluded capture for decades, assisting the task force, with Elizabeth Keen, in hunting down and capturing a global criminal.   One Redditor explained, “The Blacklist started great and went downhill. I kept watching the series, hoping it would get great again. It didn’t.”

Another added, “It felt like it was going somewhere in the first few seasons. Then, it was like the series was building up to a big finale that would pull all the strands together. Then it just didn’t happen.”

10 of the Worst Movies in the History of Cinema

Jack and Jill 1

Image Credit: Columbia Pictures

What is the worst movie that you have ever seen? According to an internet poll, there are thousands of doozies to choose from, but these are the top-ten worst.

10 Best Movie Trilogies Ever Made According to the Internet

The Dark Knight

Image Credit: Warner Bros. Pictures

What is the best movie trilogy ever made? Unfortunately, Indiana Jones and Toy Story have added a fourth film disaster following their perfect trilogy success. Otherwise, I’d nominate both of those. After asking the internet for their top contenders, these were the top ten. 

10 Greatest Single Movie Scenes Ever Filmed

man in suit

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures

What is the most remarkable single movie scene ever filmed? There are so many cinematic gems that this is a difficult question. However, after someone polled the internet, these were the top-voted responses.

Top 10 Heist Films That Are Morally Good

Indiana Jones

Image Credit: Paramount Pictures

Ever feel like rooting for the characters you know are doing something naughty, like a victimless crime? Someone asked for morally good heist movies where the crew isn’t reformed, criminals, like Ocean’s 11. Here are the top-voted heist films from the discussion. 

Top 10 Black and White Movies Absolutely Worth the Watch

Some Like It Hot 1

Image Credit: Mirisch Company

Are you a black-and-white movie fan or interested in the classics? Watching black and white films is an entirely different experience than movies in vibrant colors. Our kids thought of these classic movies as archaic, but as they got older, they became more open and less judgmental as they found some of the greatest stories, like Schindler’s List, best displayed in black and white. 


This article was produced and syndicated by The Cents of Money.

Leave a Comment